CDs Revisited: AFI - 'Answer That and Stay Fashionable'

image via Amazon.
I remember when AFI released Sing the Sorrow and hit it huge, one of my "fun facts" to pull out in a conversation about them was that AFI used to be a hardcore punk band. (There was a reason I didn't get invited to a lot of parties in high school.) I only knew a handful of songs that I had found using Kazaa (I hadn't quite made my way to Limewire yet) but that didn't stop me from acting like I was some kind of big fan of their old stuff, and I'm sure I was overly smug about it every time- making it sound as if I believed anyone who didn't know was a poser. (Now that I think about it, there's probably a reason why I still don't get invited to a lot of parties to this day.)

What I don't remember, however, is when I finally went out and bought a copy of Answer That and Stay Fashionable. It was likely some point during the second half of my sophomore year of high school, and I'm 90% sure that I bought it at the Best Buy not too far from my school, but that's just speculation. These days I don't really consider myself to be much of an AFI fan regardless of the era, but I would go as far as to say that I'm a fan of Sing the Sorrow (more on that whenever that album pops up), and this album. Everything else I enjoy bits and pieces of, but overall I don't think I really enjoy most AFI albums all the way through.

The differences between Answer That and Stay Fashionable and Sing the Sorrow (other than the obvious sonic differences, duh) are vast though. Whereas I find Sing the Sorrow to be a conceptually incredible album (again, more on that album to come in the future), what I really enjoy about Answer That and Stay Fashionable is that it's obnoxious. It's snotty punk rock with songs about meathead jocks, staying in bed all day, listening to the Misfits, and various breakfast cereals. It's not great, or even all that revolutionary in the same way that those early punk and hardcore records were, but it's got the energetic music and apathetic lyrics that made punk rock so appealing to bored youth in the 90's (or seeing as how I discovered this album in 2004, bored youth of any era, really).

Final verdict: It's a fine album. Not AFI at their best, but no one ever agrees on when AFI's best is anyway (but usually when someone argues in favor of early AFI, I feel like Very Proud of Ya and especially Shut Your Mouth and Open Your Eyes are cited more frequently as being at the top)

Stream Answer That and Stay Fashionable below and tell me all about how incredibly wrong I am for thinking that it's not mind-blowingly great or revolutionary.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

CDs Revisited: The Hextalls - 'Play With Heart'

Image
I sure own a lot of pop punk albums. I got this one as a part of a sale that The Hextalls were having right around the time of this album's release: four of their studio albums on CD and a shirt. I was never a huge fan of them, but it seemed like a pretty good deal for a band that I kind of liked. The Hextalls are a weird band for me to try to dissect. Bands like this don't seem to be writing music for the prestige or wide-spread mainstream recognition. They're writing music for fun- which can still be picked apart by critics but it doesn't feel right to me to take a critical look at songs like "Welcome to Pooville" or "I Bought You a Singing Toilet" under the same lens that I might use for a song like The Gaslight Anthem's "Get Hurt" or something like "Hands Down" by Dashboard Confessional. When it comes to pop punk bands that write these jokey kinds of songs, it feels like they really just need to write fun songs that ca...
Read more

Dustin's Best of 2017, #4: Charly Bliss - 'Guppy'

Image
What do I even say about this album? I listened to it after reading about Charly Bliss for the first time on The AV Club in April. My immediate reaction was wondering how I hadn't heard of them sooner. As a rather large consumer of pop music, Guppy  was everything I didn't even know I wanted from a band in 2017. I know that this album has been near the top of plenty of publications' end of year lists and I'm pretty sure they all go into great detail about what makes this album so good. Charly Bliss have all the makings of what made 90's power-pop and garage bands so fun, and if we lived in another era, they would have certainly been a mixtape band. I can imagine it now: "Scare U" for your high school crush, "DQ" for your younger cousin who just needs a nudge in the right direction to start liking good music, "Glitter" for yourself after your high school crush inevitably turns you down (or a heartbroken friend). It's all there. ...
Read more

Dustin's Best of 2017, #14: Direct Hit! / PEARS - 'Human Movement'

Image
Pop punk and hardcore punk are two of my favorite genres of music. My first musical obsession was Green Day, and after my uncle found I had started listening to punk rock (like a lot of people, after discovering Green Day I quickly moved to the Ramones and The Clash), he gave me copies of Group Sex  and Complete Discography  for my birthday. They're the two genres I've been listening to for nearly all of my life, and I'll have a special place for both of them in my heart. That's what makes both Direct Hit! and PEARS so great in my mind. One moment they can be playing happy-go-lucky pop punk with a catchy sing-along chorus, and the next they're screaming their throats raw and breaking down. They're a perfect match for each other on this split LP. Sometimes I'm critical of split albums, but sometimes split albums are made up of previously released tracks and I can't help but wonder what the point of it is. Other times, I love split albums, and those ti...
Read more